Which Data Source is Best? SDK vs. Bid Stream vs. Beacon

Let’s talk location.

Get original insights, informed comment, and thought leadership from the team as well as from our partners and customers, as we shape the market together.

Which Data Source is Best?
Amy Fox

One of the biggest challenges marketers face as they embark on advanced location-based advertising is understanding location data sources. GPS is the gold standard for location data; it’s accurate down to five meters. That’s what every marketer hopes to achieve in terms of accuracy, but it’s not always easy. Not all location data is created equally, and some sources are more accurate than others.

With so many different data sources available, it can be hard to know which is the best to use in any given campaign – and to know if one or many should be used. To simplify things a bit, here’s a brief description of each of the three most-used data sources, along with the pros and cons of each:

SDK (software development kit)

An SDK is essentially a piece of code that sits inside an app. The developer who’s built the app includes code that tells the app to collect location data constantly and consistently. Apps like Facebook and Apple’s “Find My Friends” are great examples of apps that use and SDK track your location 24/7. Note that these apps must have express user permission to collect location information.

  • Pros: SDKs offer fantastic data collection. They can map a single device’s location throughout the day very accurately, which makes it easy for marketers to track patterns like daily trips to the gym or coffee shop.
  • Cons: The biggest disadvantage to SDK data is scale. Because tracking location data around the clock can be a drain on a mobile phone’s battery, many developers are hesitant to include this functionality. App developers know that an app that drains battery life will be uninstalled in short order, which means reduced revenue for them. That limits the number of apps that offer SDK data collection, which can be an obstacle to scaling.

Bid stream/ exchange data

This latitude/longitude (lat/long) data comes mostly from ads running on installed mobile apps. While it could potentially come from other publisher placements, it’s more likely to come from apps for this simple reason: publishers must obtain express permission to use location data. On apps, permission to use location data only needs to be granted once, and that permission is often good for the entire lifecycle of the app. However, on any mobile site, permission for location data must be given every time the user starts a new browser session. This can lead to an unpleasant user experience, and many publishers aren’t willing to risk that, so they simply don’t request that information unless there’s a specific reason – for example, if the site offers local traffic or weather reports.

  • Pros: The greatest advantage of bid stream data is that it can be easily scaled at the click of button.
  • Cons: The biggest drawback of data from the exchanges is the risk of poor quality. When location data is obtained through the bid stream, it passes through an available impression, and the lat/long is attached to that impression. Publishers must pass along the source of that impression, and those sources comprise these types, simply referred to as types One, Two and Three. Type One is GPS data, and that’s the gold standard. Types Two and Three are less accurate and may be user-input data that is assumed to reflect their location – but it isn’t always correct. If I’m checking the weather in Florida because I’m about to travel there from New York, the data might actually place me in Florida based on the information I’ve provided. (This is why Blis only uses Type One data.) Even Type One data has to be checked for accuracy, because not all publishers – whether deliberately or out of ignorance – provide correct source data. There are also concerns about fraud with bid stream data.

Beacon data

This data is collected with actual hardware, similar to Wi-Fi hotspots, or to the Bluetooth boxes that were installed a decade ago to beam offers to nearby shoppers. While less scalable than other data sources, they are still quite exciting. Beacons work with SDKs within apps, and deliver incredibly accurate location data.

  • Pros: The greatest advantage of beacon data is its accuracy. Marketers can see not only whether someone has been in a store, but how long they’ve spent in a particular aisle within that store. Today, it’s an excellent way for marketers to see if audiences are being driven into businesses. In the future, we may see CPG brands adding beacon-sensitive chips to particular products so they can collect data about which products end up in the shopping cart. Can you imagine the advances that would bring to attribution?
  • Cons: The biggest issues with beacons relate to scale. Beacons rely on SDKs and Bluetooth to collect data. Not only does a consumer need to have an app with the SDK running, they also need to have Bluetooth turned on. (Keep in mind, as more and more connected devices – including the newest iPhones and Air Pods – enter the market, a larger number of consumers will keep their Bluetooth on, so this will become less of an issue.) The other disadvantage is that the beacon is actually hardware, so it does need to be purchased and installed in every location.

There’s really no bad way to choose data. As we’ve illustrated, each source has its benefits and its challenges, but they all work together well to paint a picture of your audience. The best course is not to put all your money on one horse: use all three, and use as many sources as possible – but be prepared to check the accuracy of any and all the data you choose.

Next up in the series: What’s post-bid verification, and is it something you need to keep your campaigns safe from fraud?

Tags: , ,

Amy Fox is Head of Product at Blis and is responsible for high level product strategy and development alongside the release of new revenue streams and products into the market. As one of the original Blis employees, Amy has grown her career over the last few years from an entry level role in partner relationships through to heading up both Operations and Product sequentially.
Most recent blog posts
Partner Spotlight: Q&A with RSi’s Ansa

Article

Partner Spotlight: Q&A with RSi’s Ansa

Question 1: How long have you been at RSi and what is your role?
For the past three years, I have been responsible for creating and scaling Ansa, a web-based solution from RSi – Retail Solutions, Inc., that has enabled over 75 of the world’s largest CPG companies and their agencies to build, measure and maximize the performance of their shopper marketing campaigns running in support of the nation’s leading retailers. I am responsible for all aspects of business development, partner and agency relationships and the overall revenue growth of Ansa.

Question 2: How does RSi help solve marketer challenges?
Shopper marketers’ biggest challenge is to connect their online campaigns to in-store results. RSi’s Ansa solution provides the intelligence they need, based on daily, store-level POS-data from the largest US retailers in order to plan, target, and measure the impact of their shopper marketing campaigns. Retail Solutions Inc. has partnered with the leading ad networks in Shopper Marketing, such as Blis, to make Ansa’s automated analytics available for the world’s largest CPG companies and their agencies. To measure and maximize their digital ad campaigns, all they need to do is ask for Ansa inside their next campaign.

Question 3: What benefits does the partnership with Blis bring to buyers as well as the adtech ecosystem?
With RSi’s Ansa solution, building, dynamically optimizing, and reviewing attribution measures for every digital ad campaign has never been so simple. Here is how it works:
1. STORE-LEVEL TARGETING: automatically get from Ansa your store targeting data as store addresses, lat/longs or by Ansa Digital ZIPs to identify stores with the greatest sales potential prior to launching hyper-local media.
2. IN-FLIGHT OPTIMIZATION: see in real-time how sales are trending in your targeted stores vs. a 52-week historical average, and get access to dynamic optimization lists that can guide budget reallocation.
3. MEASUREMENT & INSIGHTS: get access via the online portal to end of campaign analysis just days after the media campaign is over. Visualizations give you a standardized set of analytics, such as sales lift, incremental dollars and units, confidence level, weekly lift, characteristics of high performing stores, etc. Prove and improve your media to help you fine-tune strategies for your future campaigns.

Question 4: What are use cases for the Blis + RSi partnership? (Please provide a few examples from different verticals).
If you are a shopper marketer, maximizing your budgets, understanding performance of your marketing tactics and generating key learnings from those marketing tactics are tasks that are essential to your business.

Running a digital marketing campaign with Blis, and Ansa’s daily, store-level sales intelligence helps make that extremely for the CPG community and shopper marketers specifically.

For existing products, Blis campaigns using Ansa targeting can reach a targeting efficiency of 2:1 vs. campaigns that do not use Ansa store-level targeting thereby ensuring that every dollar is spent driving sales to your most important retailer locations.

Blis campaigns optimized with Ansa typically identify and heavy up investment around 16% of stores that are trending significantly ahead of the average store during a campaign and identify and decrease investment around 14% of stores that are trending significantly behind the average store, therefore ensuring that your budget is being optimized surrounding stores that are over-performing during a given campaign.

After each Blis campaign, Ansa automatically generates measurement of Featured Item Lift and Halo Item Lift at both the total event and week levels. Results are completed 5 business days after the end of each campaign and allow you to learn quickly and improve continuously, all at an amazingly affordable price.

Question 5: What shopper marketing measurement trends do you predict for 2018?
Optimization in-flight based on store sales trends during campaign. Optimizing on engagement, intent and / or clicks may be ok for some campaigns but more and more frequently shopper marketers are tasked with driving sales at their most important retailers. And understanding how their marketing tactics performed 5-6 weeks after a campaign has finished is just not fast enough anymore in today’s fast paced world and puts media providers at a severe disadvantage. By utilizing automated reporting that allows Ansa partners like Blis to understand and optimize their media in-flight based on daily, store-level POS sales data you now empower your media partner to act on supporting the stores that are driving your product sales which can ultimately provide a powerful boost to a shopper marketing campaign.

Question 6: If there was one piece of content you think every marketer should read, what is it?
(Other than this blog post of course!)

Think with Google and Facebook IQ are two fantastic sources of resources. Articles, trends, case studies, POVs, insights, etc… pretty much everything you need to read to keep you up-to-speed in this very fast-paced environment.

Read more

Meet, Greet and Keep: How Mobile Can Help Brands Throughout the Sales Funnel

Article

Meet, Greet and Keep: How Mobile Can Help Brands...

Our mobile devices give us more than just a way to call or text friends and family: Today, they are our maps, books, radios, and miniature shopping malls. We turn to them for news, entertainment and answers. And from dawn till dusk, we keep them at our sides like our most faithful companions.

So it’s no wonder mobile devices have become integral to an advertiser’s ability to reach their ideal audiences at every stage of the sales funnel. Here’s how brands can employ effective mobile advertising strategies to acquire, engage and retain customers.

Win Over New Customers

One of the best ways for advertisers to identify new audiences is to see where they shop. But without access to a competitor’s first-party purchase data or information about their website traffic, how can advertisers find this out?

Mobile devices provide the answer. By revealing where consumers go, mobile location data can tell brands which consumers spend their time browsing similar products at a competitor’s store. Let’s say Target wants to reach out to consumers who usually shop at Walmart. They can use location data to identify—then target—those who frequently visit the competitor yet still live near a Target store.

But brands need to be careful before jumping to conclusions about consumers. Real-time location data provides important insights, but they can be strengthened when paired with historical location data.

For example, just because someone visits a high-end boutique like Chanel, it doesn’t mean that person has the budget to shop there—they could just be browsing. How can an upscale fashion brand find out which of those Chanel visitors are actually potential shoppers? Here, historical location data can help. It can reveal, for instance, which of those visitors go to private airports a few times a month or regularly visit Giorgio Armani or Versace stores. Chances are, these consumers will be a better bet for the fashion brand seeking to acquire new customers.

Keep Them Interested

What’s the first thing you do when you wake up in the morning? For most of us, it’s look at our phones to turn off our alarms before checking the weather and scrolling through our Twitter feeds. And throughout the day, we continue to stare down into the faces of our mobile devices: checking the news on the train, sending an email between meetings, or watching videos from our living room sofas.

In order to engage consumers on the devices we use day in and day out, advertisers will need to serve ads that make sense for the consumer depending on where they are during the day. To do this, advertisers must first ask the question: What do consumers want to see on their mobile devices and when? Consumers spend a third of their time online watching videos, for instance, but they aren’t going to watch a 30-second video ad while walking down the street.

To boost engagement, brands can use knowledge about a consumer’s historical and real-time whereabouts to reach out at the time and place that will produce the greatest level of engagement. To effectively grab the attention of a consumer that’s out and about, a banner ad may work best. Later that evening, when the consumer is at home using a tablet or laptop, a longer video on a larger screen may work well.

Inspire Loyalty

How can brands make sure they retain the new and existing customers they’ve worked so hard to gain? They must first recognize and show appreciation for their most loyal customers.

Most advertisers identify loyal customers by looking at newsletter subscriptions and online purchase histories, but they may be missing other valuable customers who prefer to shop in stores. By identifying devices that frequently visit a brand’s store location, advertisers can make sure they are recognizing—and thanking—all their biggest fans. When an existing customer comes into a store a certain number of times, for example, advertisers can deliver a thank-you message—perhaps offering the loyal customer a generous coupon to redeem in-store.

Read more

Retailers’ Golden Ticket to Reviving Brick and Mortar Stores

Article

Retailers’ Golden Ticket to Reviving Brick and Mortar Stores

Interested in understanding how to connect mobile experiences to physical stores? Or how mobile can be the extension of a retailer’s store? Maybe you’ve wondered about the new Cost-Per-Visit metric? Look no further. Blis’ location data experts will be answering these questions on a weekly basis over the next few months in our ‘Retail Series’ which aims to equip retail marketers with the right insights and top tips to stay ahead of the game.

Following its decision to buy e-commerce company Jet.com last year, Walmart recently agreed to acquire Bonobos, a retailer with a strong online presence and generous shipping policies. If these moves weren’t sign enough that the physical and digital retail worlds are merging, Amazon’s acquisition of Whole Foods is the ultimate wake-up call.

Retailers everywhere are realizing that while brick and mortar stores are still critical, they’ll need a strong digital strategy to keep them filled with happy customers. Mobile devices are retailers’ golden ticket to connecting with consumers and reviving in-store shopping.

Understanding Consumers though Mobile

Whether they are going to work or going shopping, consumers carry their phones with them wherever they go. As a result, mobile devices provide retailers with a constant stream of valuable consumer insights. GPS and Wi-Fi data can tell retailers, for instance, whether a consumer is at a desktop at work, connected to Wi-Fi at home, or walking past a retailer’s store.

Beyond real-time location data, retailers can use historical location data to understand a consumer’s habits. For example, some consumers might visit a luxury jewelry brand on Fifth Avenue just to browse, even if they have no intention (or monetary means!) of buying. Thus, for that specific retailer, in-store visits may not indicate ideal customers. Instead, that luxury retailer can look at historical location data to identify their ideal consumers: perhaps individuals who frequently stay at the Four Seasons Hotel or regularly check in to exclusive country clubs.

But retailers shouldn’t rely on mobile data alone. By layering mobile insights with other valuable sources of data, advertisers can gain a holistic picture of their perfect audiences. Data collected from laptops, for instance, can reveal browsing histories and online shopping patterns; however, consumers won’t be opening up their laptops while shopping in stores. The trick is for retailers to match the data across devices to unique mobile device IDs. Only then will they gain a more holistic understanding of consumers and will be able to target or retarget them with products they are likely to go buy.

Driving Foot Traffic Creatively

Once they’ve gotten a clear and thorough understanding of their ideal audiences, how can retailers use mobile devices to drive foot traffic? Proximity targeting—delivering ads to consumers when they come within a certain distance of a store location—is a common approach. Retailers can maximize the power of proximity targeting by crafting unique and imaginative creatives.

For instance, advertisers can deliver ads to shoppers already in the area to tell them about an in-store sale, or offer them a coupon they can only redeem in person. Retailers can also deliver ads that feature a handy map telling consumers how to find their store.

Sometimes, targeting consumers when they are walking by a store may be a little too late. A QSR wanting to boost its 10 am breakfast crowd, for instance, may want to target consumers when they wake up around 7a and begin planning their day. Otherwise, the consumer has most likely already made their breakfast choice.

While there is no one-size-fits-all solution for retailers looking to connect with consumers and drive in-store sales, a strong mobile strategy is key. As the digital and physical worlds continue to blend, retailers must harness the insights and capabilities of mobile to reach their unique brand objectives.

Tune in next week to read all about how mobile is fast becoming the extension of a retailer’s store.

Read more